Tuesday, March 17, 2015

The American Execution Contradiction.



If nothing else, the USA is the land of paradox. For example, more than three hundred million people occupy it. Yet the vast majority of the population is squeezed into California, the north east states and some southern states, while states like Wyoming and Montana, two of the most beautiful states, are sparsely occupied. Go to a baseball game. Before a ball is pitched, someone holding a microphone will lead the singing of the national anthem, praising the States as the land of the free. But at any given time, some two percent of the American population is incarserated in a federal or state prison.

The Declaration of Independence seeks to guarantee certain inalienable rights. Thomas Jefferson and colleagues were eager to protect “life,” as well as liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Yet America's federal government and thirty-two states maintain the death penalty on their statute books. Thus a majority of Americans live under laws which include the legal right for the state to execute people, ending their lives before the natural span has expired. It occurs to me that the Declaration of Independence suffers from a lack of clarity. Should it not have guaranteed "the right to life, provided the law is not transgressed and a capital crime committed?"

There is a fundamental question. Should any state or nation have the right to withdraw human life? My belief is that it should not. Too many mistakes have been made over the years and people have been wrongly executed. Setting my personal views aside, America remains the only western democracy that retains the right to curtail life. Why is it so out of step with its political partners?

I have written before about the death penalty so why am I going down this route again? In a word, Utah. The state government of Utah has decided to alter its method of execution. It can no longer purchase lethal injection chemicals. Evidently, the sole supplier is the EU, which will no longer oblige. Is there no other concoction? Veterinary surgeons all over the country put dogs "to sleep" every day. They administer an anaethsetic, followed by a drug that stops the heart. Cannot something similar be found for humans in America?

Faced with the dilemma, the Utah legislators have decided to reinstate the firing squad, a method that was outlawed by the state more than ten years ago. Talk about going back to the dark ages. A Utah legislator said, "It will only take a few seconds for people to die. It’s a quick bleed out." This punishment seems cruel and unusual, offending the 8th Amendment. Will Governor Herbert, a Republican, sign the bill into law? His term of office expires next year. If he wishes to run again, does he need to be seen to be tough on crime?

Currently, Utah has five people on death row. How will they feel about being shot to death? Why should we care? These people have been convicted of capital crimes and have received the benefit of a two phase trial. Does it matter how they die? The answer must be “yes” as the Supreme Court has often considered the ways and means of lethal execution.

Utah is a beautiful state, Salt Lake City excepted. How can its citizens be happy with a law which will sully the state's reputation? As for the shooters themselves, did they sign up to kill in cold blood? The death penalty is an aspect of American life which I find beyond belief.


Friday, March 6, 2015

Obamacare Under Challenge


Americans are fond of saying that “the President is the most powerful man in the world.” It is true that he has an array of weaponry at his disposal that could blow up the world seventeen times before breakfast. But, as Lyndon Johnson famously remarked about the conduct of the Vietnam War, “the only f***ing power I have is nuclear and I can’t use that!”

Having inherited the worst economic situation in decades from a Republican administration, the Obama administration has turned things round. For example, it has helped the car industry recover its strength. It has reduced unemployment. Abroad, it has ended its participation in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, another inheritance from the Republicans. Yet Obama is under fire. This time, he faces a challenge in the Supreme Court which has taken up the Affordable Care Act, better known as Obamacare, for the third time.

The Supreme Court case is the latest effort by political opponents to wreck President Obama’s most important domestic achievement, the Affordable Care Act. If the Supremes find for the plaintiffs, Obama’s legacy will be tarnished, it will foment infighting among Republicans, augment partisanship, not to mention hatred, between the GOP Congress and the White House, and cause enormous chaos in the health insurance market. Worst of all, an estimated 9.6 million people would lose their health insurance cover.

The lawsuit before the Court, King v. Burwell, is unlike the previous two Obamacare cases that have been brought to the Supreme Court. Three years ago, in National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius, Chief Justice John Roberts joined the court’s four liberals in upholding the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate, permitting most Americans to obtain government-supported health insurance. Last year in Hobby Lobby v. Burwell, the Court weakened ACA birth-control coverage, a case which had religious freedom implications. The case was GOP inspired.

The ACA entitles Americans to buy health insurance through insurance exchanges. Thirteen states have established an exchange. The other thirty seven have not, but the federal government provides exchanges instead. Yesterday, the Court heard oral arguments in King v Burwell, a lawsuit engineered by conservative and libertarian think tanks who claim a handful of words within the ACA, “an exchange established by the state,” makes it illegal for the federal government to provide healthcare insurance whilst issuing tax credits in those  states using federal health insurance exchanges

The plaintiffs’ assertion has dire implications for low and moderate income people receiving those subsidies in states where the federal government, not the state, created a health insurance exchange. Just thirteen states and the District of Columbia are fully operating these marketplaces.

As of last month, 8.8 million people had taken private health insurance policies through the exchanges in the thirty seven states that use the FederalHealthCare.gov system. Millions more have used state-based marketplaces. According to a recent article in The Washington Post, since sign-ups began in October 2013, the share of customers on federal exchanges receiving tax credits for their coverage has been above 85 percent. According to data from the Department of Health and Human Services, the average value of those subsidies is $268 a month, bringing down the average monthly price to $105 for subsidized enrollees.

The ruling is expected in June. If the Supreme Court sides with the plaintiffs, a majority of the public will demand the subsidies restored, according to a survey by the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. Their poll revealed that 64 percent of Americans believe Congress should enact a fix, and 59 percent think their own states should set up health insurance exchanges.

But a fix may never come. Congress could have made the Supreme Court hearing unnecessary by passing a simple amendment clarifying the intent of the Affordable Care Act. The Congressional Republicans have adamantly refused to consider this. The Obama administration maintains there’s nothing it can do on its own to mitigate the disappearance of subsidies.

It is a disgrace that the current Republican-controlled Congress should defy not only the will of a previous Congress but also a Supreme Court ruling that Obamacare was lawful, as well as the wishes of the majority of Americans. I have written on many occasions about the hypocrisy of legislators who enjoy, at taxpayers’ expense, the best medical health insurance plans but seek to deny protection to millions of their fellow citizens.

It is my understanding that the states could evade the consequences of an adverse Court ruling by establishing their own health insurance exchanges. However, Republicans control at least one branch of government in nearly all of the affected states and would probably block any such proposal. None has taken steps to begin the contentious, time-consuming and costly effort to do so.

A recent poll by the Urban Institute suggests that of those who would lose coverage, 62 percent live in Southern states, mostly governed by Republicans, 81 percent are employed and 61 percent are white. With an election looming next year, surely the Congressional Republicans should reconsider their position in the light of potential vote losses. Furthermore, the disruption would not be limited to people who qualify for health insurance subsidies. It would have profound effects on health insurance markets, often Republican led, in the affected states.


Having briefly read the reports of yesterday’s hearings, the justices seem to be keeping to their ideologies. If so, the ruling might sink ACA and restore millions of people to the position they had before 2013, worrying about their finances should they need medical care. How does this equate with the much vaunted American ideal of fairness? Mr Spock of Star Trek fame said it best: “The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.” It is to be hoped that the Supremes heed the spirit of the law, not its letter, and throw out the law suit.

Wednesday, March 4, 2015

Alice in Wonderland Meets Congressional Republicans


Recent machinations in Congress reminded me of an exchange in Lewis Carroll’s “Alice in Wonderland. “ Substituting Congressional Republicans for Alice and John Boehner for the Cheshire Cat, the following conversation might occur:
Republican: “I don’t want to go among mad people.”
JB: “Oh, you can’t help that, we’re all mad here. I’m mad, you’re mad.”
Republican: “How do you know I’m mad?”
JB: “You must be or you wouldn’t have come here.”
Republicans, who now control both Houses of Congress, are unable to agree on how to respond to President Obama's immigration policies. Recently he issued Executive Orders which would shield an estimated five million undocumented immigrants from deportation. Conservative Republicans have added a rider to a bill extending funding for the Department of Homeland Security, cancelling the Executive Orders. DHS funding expires this Friday. The Democrats aren’t budging and the Republicans cannot get the funding bill through.
Speaker of the House, John Boehner, plans to hold a vote on a bill that would extend DHS funding for another three weeks. What is the point of setting an arbitrary deadline for such a short time? The expression, “kicking the can down the road,” comes to mind. Has Boehner the 218 votes he needs to pass this short-term bill? If not, DHS funding will expire. 
If the House bill passes, the House and Senate will have just three weeks to bridge their fundamental differences on funding DHS for the long term and, at the same time, block President Obama’s changes to immigration policy. In addition, Congress must update a complicated Medicare reimbursement formula for doctors. And it needs to pass the budget. There is a logjam down the road, not just a tin can, and a major governance failure for the Republican Congress. GOP leaders have vowed to avoid such problems but we have heard all this before.
Republicans will continue their internal debate over whether to partially close DHS and protest President Obama’s immigration actions. The party has virtually no chance of forcing Obama to roll back his immigration plans. Senate Democrats will almost certainly filibuster any legislation that blocks Obama’s executive orders, just as they did in January and February. Even if Senate Republicans manage to eliminate filibusters, as Democrats did during the last Congress, they don’t have the votes to overcome a presidential veto. Republicans have only one other form of leverage: cut off DHS funding in hopes that Obama will roll back his immigration plans.
For now, the president’s executive orders on immigration are on indefinite hold after a federal judge last month temporarily suspended them in response to a 26-state lawsuit challenge. The Obama administration will appeal the decision, which will prolong the legal battle into next year, especially if the case moves to the Supreme Court.

President Obama has never conceded to shutdown threats. Furthermore, the last partial government closure in 2013 hurt Republicans’ approval ratings far more than his own. It’s unclear what Republicans will do about DHS this week, but one thing is certain: a shutdown alone will not negate the recent immigration orders. Will we see John Boehner adopt the role of another “Alice” character, the Mad Hatter, and run around the House saying, “clean vote?”

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

History and Hollywood and Selma.

Martin Luther King with President LBJ after the civil rights act was signed.


Harry Longabaugh is a famous American criminal. Who is he? You would know him better as the Sundance Kid, the character played by Robert Redford in the epic western, “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.” When he was aged fifteen, Harry travelled from Pennsylvania to the West and settled in a town later called Sundance, Wyoming. Most people would tell you that Sundance and Butch were gunned down in a hail of bullets in a Bolivian mountain village by hundreds of militia-men. However, a visit to the Sundance Museum will provide a different story. The Sundance Kid, according to locals, lived to a good age. Hollywood, as the saying goes, was economical with the truth.

This is hardly the first time that Hollywood has changed history to suit its purposes. Often, such changes are inconsequential. In the final scene of “The Green Berets,” John Wayne is seen watching the sun go down on a Vietnam beach. One quick look at a map of Vietnam will tell you that all Vietnam beaches face east, so the movement of the earth around the sun would need to be reversed to establish the Hollywood version.

The most ridiculous piece of fiddling with fact came in the move, “Krakatoa, East of Java.” The film tells the story of one of the deadliest volcanic events in recorded history. I have not seen the movie so cannot comment on how it dealt with the history. However, there is a problem with the film’s title. I, and pretty well any eight year old who looks at a map of Java, will tell you that Krakatoa is west of Java. What could have possessed the director or the film’s producers to want to make nonsense of basic geography?

Why have I got the bit between my teeth on Hollywood’s historiographical unreliability? Last week, I saw the film, “Selma.” Martin Luther King was portrayed as a highly intelligent, articulate leader who had his weaknesses and faults but was prepared to give everything for the cause of black civil rights. So far, so good. Even if the film’s scenes of violence perpetrated against blacks by white authority and associate thugs were exaggerated, there is sufficient evidence of what happened to the Freedom Riders in Mississippi and the children of Birmingham Alabama, where Sheriff Bull Connor turned Alsatian (German Shepherd) dogs on them in the full glare of television cameras, to accept that treatment of blacks was worse than deplorable.

However, according to the film, MLK had to persuade, cajole and threaten President Lyndon Johnson to pass the 1965 Voting Rights Act. Omitting the issue that in America, Congress, not the President, makes the laws, the role played by LBJ in achieving civil rights for the black community, as portrayed in the film, is both wrong and deceitful. The black American community never had a better friend and supporter in the White House than LBJ. He championed the passing of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, a piece of legislation that LBJ’s predecessor neither supported wholeheartedly nor had the ability to move it through Congress.

“Selma” suggests that LBJ felt he had done enough for African Americans by having the Civil Rights Act passed. It is important to record that history shows a totally different set of facts. In 1964, LBJ knew that had he tried to include voting rights in the civil rights legislation, the Southern Democrats in Congress would defeat any bill. So, LBJ exercised patience, preferring to wait for re-election before tackling the issue of black voting rights. There is ample evidence to support the contention that MLK was not only well aware of this but supported LBJ’s view.

The passage of the Voting Rights Act was tortuous. Getting a bill through Congress can sometimes be as difficult as threading a camel through the eye of a needle. There are committees in both Houses which have power to block any legislation and stop it reaching a floor vote. LBJ played politics brilliantly to jump all the Congressional hurdles and deliver the Voting Rights Act within five months of his inauguration.

Had Selma’s producers told the truth of the part played by LBJ, would King’s role have been minimised? The film could have shown how, even in 1965, a black man could work with the chief executive for the benefit of a minority community. Instead, LBJ has been depicted as recalcitrant and prejudiced, and worse, as someone who failed to understand the plight of African Americans.


So many people who see “Selma” will not know the real historical truth. This is a disservice to students of history and the black American community as well as all who advocate equality and civil rights. It is a pity that the film’s director and producers lost a great opportunity to tell the far more powerful, truthful story. 

Monday, February 16, 2015

Who Would Want to Lead on Capitol Hill?


Some six weeks ago, the newly re-elected Senate Majority Leader, Mitch McConnell promised that he and his colleagues would not shut down the federal government.  Well, we all know the relationship between politicians and promises. “Ending in tears,” comes to mind.
At the moment, the Congressional legislators are on a break. When they return next week, there will be only four days to approve next year’s funding of the Department of Homeland Security, the massive agency created by the George W Bush administration. There is a problem. The DHS budget is at risk, not because the Democrats in Congress object, nor because the executive branch might not approve it. The problem arises because GOP Senate conservatives want to roll back President Obama’s recent executive orders on immigration. They can do this by adding a rider to the funding bill, even though the rider may have no relationship to the content of the bill.
Republican conservatives are determined that DHS, which seeks to protect the security of all Americans within USA, will not be funded unless the legislation overrules President Obama’s recent executive orders on immigration. These executive orders temporarily prevent the deportation of millions of illegal immigrants. I emphasise that the effect of the orders is to defer the deportations of people, many of whom have lived, worked and paid taxes in America for many years
The House of Representatives has passed a DHS funding bill which includes provisions striking down the executive orders on immigration. However, Senate Democrats, some of whom opposed the executive orders, have blocked the House-passed legislation in the Senate, using repeated filibusters. So, McConnell is trapped within a legislative box that he had vowed to avoid. He knows that government shutdowns damage the US political party which causes them.
McConnell is on record that he is determined not to repeat the mistakes of previous years when the Republicans brought the federal government to a standstill.  On the day after he won re-election, McConnell said: “Let me make it clear: There will be no government shutdowns.” Yet, last week, McConnell acknowledged the Senate was stuck and he was in need of House Speaker John Boehner’s help. Sadly for McConnell, the Speaker was not in a charitable mood. Boehner said he had no interest in passing revised legislation through the House just to draw Democratic support in the Senate.
A shutdown of one agency would not cause the same disruption as the October 2013 shutdown of the federal government, which resulted in national parks closing, furloughs of hundreds of thousands of federal workers and a general sense of disgust with Washington dysfunction. If no deal is reached, the Department of Homeland Security would deem many workers essential, particularly those overseeing border security, airline safety, disaster responses and domestic terror assessments. Yet even those federal workers would have no assurance of being paid.
Public reaction would probably mirror ­the events of October 2013, when Republicans tried to force Mr. Obama to accept a funding plan that would have gutted his landmark health-care law. The ensuing shutdown badly damaged public support for Republicans, leaving them in a hole that took them almost a year to recover from.
McConnell is adamant about not repeating the mistake. “I don’t think a shutdown of the department whose purpose is to secure our homeland is a good idea for anybody,” Some McConnell advisers suggest that a brief lapse in funding for one federal agency would not break his no-shutdowns promise. Talk about stretching the truth! McConnell has made no recent public mention of the DHS showdown, sticking to his comments that Speaker Boehner will have to make the next move.
The DHS has been given a short-term extension of funds until Feb. 27, buying time for McConnell and Boehner to come up with an escape plan. None has yet appeared, nor from the sound of Boehner’s pronouncements will the House offer help. I had to smile when I read the comments of Senator John Cornyn, McConnell’s top lieutenant on the leadership team. “I have every confidence we will meet the deadline, one way or the other. Just how, I can’t tell you right this minute.”
Democrats said even a small-scale shutdown, so soon on McConnell’s watch, would hurt him politically. They believe it would set a precedent, with the far right wing pushing him around in the same manner that House conservatives have backed Boehner into corners he wanted to avoid.
There is time to avert a shutdown, but it almost certainly involves capitulation to the Democrats. One possibility is to remove the immigration sections from the House and Senate bills and pass a clean funding bill. However, such a move would probably prompt a huge backlash from conservative Republicans. Another option is to pass a short-term extension of DHS funding for a few more weeks or months though kicking the can down the road is no real solution. There is also the choice of letting DHS funding dry up and see what happens.

If nothing else, this episode shows how difficult it is for Congress to pass legislation, even when one political party is in control of both Houses of Congress.